In an attempt to catch up a bit, let’s tackle the next challenge. The task is simple. Ask a compelling question and let you, the reader, comment and thus have the compelling story be told in the comments and not in the post itself.

Here’s my question(s): Those of you who use Twitter, what do you think makes it so compelling and sticky (i.e., challenging to walk away from)? Those of you who don’t use Twitter, have you tried it and walked away or are you avoiding it altogether? Either way, why?

I know a number of you have answered this question in one context or another, but I’d like to see a nice long list of responses that might help someone looking at Twitter for the first time see many sides of the Twitter discussion. Give me three words. Or give me three paragraphs. Fire away.

Tags:

This entry was posted on Thursday, May 15th, 2008 at 9:55 pm and is filed under Bloggery, Professional Development. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

32 comments so far

 1 

For me, Twitter means that I can have learn from some of the most important and well-respected people in their fields - and then go into what we’re having for lunch. :)

May 15th, 2008 at 11:24 pm
 2 

I think Twitter works on at least two levels for me. It encourages me to narrate my own life in 140 character bursts, and once I started doing that, it was hard to get my brain to stop. I nuked my first Twitter account because I was doing that way too much, and it was interfering with my everyday life, taking me out of the moment as I thought about how I would type it up for Twitter.

But I came back to Twitter for the other level: the community. I wanted to be able to post a message to my whole online social network in one fell swoop. And I enjoy getting those messages from others. I have more or less learned to take it easy and avoid the problem with the first level.

Lastly, there are some people who are just really funny/compelling in the Twitter format.

May 15th, 2008 at 11:25 pm
 3 

I’ve wondered the same thing. But I think I miss it so much when it’s not there because I get lonely for the community.

It’s also really simple to use, which I don’t think should be underestimated as a factor in “stickiness.” I don’t have to pick and chose features, and there aren’t 15 different ways to contact people. I don’t have to open a “new post” and there’s no room for long thoughts, so it forces me to interact less formally than a forum or blog might.

Which brings me back to the community idea. It’s really REALLY hard to maintain a persona on twitter, and the community is generally dismissive of mini-newsletter twitterers, which means that we get to know each other much as we might if we were able to have lunch every day. It’s a completely different kind of knowing each other than if we convened once a day for a round of presentations, or even a seminar-type discussion.

May 15th, 2008 at 11:49 pm
 4 

Twitter isn’t a bit sticky for me. But it sits on my desktop (in Twhirl) and chirps from time to time keeping me linked to my desk friends. I love their wit and expertise … and you never know when a new idea is going to drop into your life. 140 characters? No problem. Keeps it short and sweet.

May 16th, 2008 at 1:46 am
 5 

Twitter is addictive in that I don’t want to miss it at times. It takes some effort not to be there. Its great for keeping up with library goss, but also for communicating with librarians, both local and OS, who I don’t get to see, but love talking with.

May 16th, 2008 at 3:05 am
 6 

I’m like Kate. I have Twhirl open on my desktop most of the time and do enjoy seeing what people are up to, although I have to say that the reasons that people would be addicted escape me. From time to time interesting ideas and resources come through, but there’s also a lot of “noise” to sift through.

May 16th, 2008 at 5:49 am
 7 

I’m a known twitteraholic :) but I don’t think you can really explain the power of twitter unless someone lives and experiences its power. So my question back to you is where are you at with the twitter cycle?

May 16th, 2008 at 6:57 am
 8 

I hear you, Kate. I’m in an office alone, but am a very social person - Twitter is companionship.

May 16th, 2008 at 9:36 am
 9 

For me, twitter hits a sweet spot of being both productive for work and socially fun. It’s sort of a passive networking opportunity too. And the 140 character limit makes it possible to follow as a stream, instead of having to block out time to read up on new posts.

May 16th, 2008 at 9:40 am
 10 

I twitter a lot, after assuming I wouldn’t like it at all. But I’ve found it’s an excellent way of participating in a community. You don’t have to be distinctly on or off, like IM. You don’t have to go to different sites, like you do with blogs and comments. It’s ephemeral, so you can miss stuff and not feel completely left out. But when you’re engaged, so you can great conversations. I’ve really developed some friendships through Twitter (which is kind of amazing, since each post is 140 characters or less) and gotten some really good personal and professional support.

Oh, and for the longest time, I had no client for Twitter. I just habitually refreshed my Twitter page and posted straight to Twitter. This didn’t stop me from posting a lot.

May 16th, 2008 at 9:42 am
 11 

To echo Steve and Iris, it’s the community. When I’m not at my computer, I do miss knowing what my Twitter friends are doing. Part of that is because I’m nosy :) but a big part of it is that Twitter (and the LSW) provide more professional interaction than I normally get at work. The fact that tweets are only 140 characters keeps things from becoming too deep (sometimes), but I still am able to bounce ideas and problems off of my friends.

My Twitter and LSW contacts (for me the two are almost inextricably intertwined) also keep me up to date on the latest web and technology stuff. My colleagues here at work are not as interested in such things, so we don’t talk about the latest and greatest. Twitter fills that need for me.

So Twitter is sticky for me because it matches my personality and my needs well. Most of the people I know don’t “get it”, but I think that’s true of a lot of 2.0 things. There are some 2.0 things I just don’t get either, so I don’t push it.

May 16th, 2008 at 9:47 am
Lee
 12 

I haven’t completely decided yet. It’s fun and I’ve met some great new people, but I worry that it will negatively affect office productivity. Some people seem to spend a lot of time on it during their work day.

May 16th, 2008 at 9:48 am
 13 

I personally have started and stopped using Twitter a couple of times. So far as to actually delete my account once (which I then had to get reinstated). What made the difference in me using it this time? 1. I met a bunch of folks at CIL who use Twitter that I like, respect and want to be closer to. 2. Twirl

Twirl allows me to monitor things without taking up a webpage. Like Iris, I do love that I’m getting to know people that I wouldn’t otherwise know very well. I’ve had personal and professional questions answered. I’ve gotten technical help. I’ve had a place to vent or be confused… It’s great!

Yes, I’m seeing that is affecting my work. While I’m not addicted, I try to keep up with the flow of twits and some days they just keep coming in…it’s hard to keep up and not be distracted. I need to set boundaries, not go backwards to read older messages so much, or something. Once I get back from this conference and vacation, I plan to tackle this issue.

I’m not a rule creator or follower, but sometimes I wish people wouldn’t tweet so much or about the things they choose to use their 140 characters. I’m sure people can say the same about me. And my feelings all depend on my workload, amount of distraction I can handle that day, and what I’m getting out of Twitter that day. That is about personal time management, which I know we all work on daily. Some days we are good at it, some days not so much…Twitter is always there to help you out in both ways. :)

Twitter is like a constant chat room, that’s exclusively people you know or added. That’s good and bad. So far, I like it, ask me tomorrow!

Also, Twitter has great potential for conferences to keep up with friends and meet up. Course it’s helpful if you use your phone to send and receive the tweets. I don’t have an unlimited media package and I’m cheap. I don’t want to pay 15 cents for just anything. I’d pay to get the texts that say where/when people are meeting up. I wish that people would/could apply tags so I would only get the “planning” type or DM messages to my cell phone…

Must. stop. typing. now.

May 16th, 2008 at 9:50 am
 14 

One of my favorite high school teachers did an experiment with us one day. He handed everyone a stack of little slips of paper and told us to jot down whatever we were actually thinking about during class. At the end of the hour he collected them and read them out loud. They were wonderful — funny, silly, sad, even sometimes semi-profound (although all these years later, the only one I remember was one that said, “Just how much taller is Art Garfunkel than Paul Simon?” — doubtless a response to an album cover that was pinned up as part of a display for another class).

Twitter reminds me of that exercise. It reminds me that so much of what we think and feel is tangential to what we are doing but is nonetheless important, even crucial. I live so much in my head, which is populated with memories and ideas and thoughts that often bounce around in an ADD-like fashion. Twitter gives me a way to acknowledge that, even celebrate it — and it gives me a way to connect wit hall these other wonderful people whose minds seem to work in a similar fashion.

The things that connect us to other people are so varied, so messy, and Twitter seems to be a particularly good way to capture the things that make those connections and thus create a community.

May 16th, 2008 at 9:56 am
Mlibrarianus
 16 

Twitter is several things for me. I enjoy the humorous posts from colleagues (nice to get a chuckle every now and then), informative posts with links to blogs (keeps me up to date and connected), and keeps me informed as to where friends/co-workers/colleagues are (e.g. several at MLA conference right now that I’m missing).

One way that I use it on a personal note is for safety. When I’m walking the dogs in remote areas I make sure I Twitter so that in case anything “bad” should happen someone has a last known location for me.
And last but not least Twitter has connected me to others in the profession and I’m enjoying the social and professional “getting to knowness” that Twitter provides.

May 16th, 2008 at 10:15 am
royce
 17 

i hate twitter, yet i check it all the time,
some people are pretty funny
other people just bore they hell out of ya…..

May 16th, 2008 at 10:22 am
 18 

Hi, my name is Christa and I’m a twitteraholic. Why am I addicted though? Not an easy question to answer. Every time someone asks why I do it, I come up with a different answer.

Definitely networking is big. I get to communicate every day with a group of smart, funny, innovative people. I’m learning new things all the time.

Also, the personal aspect of it is great. I get to know people as more than just their blog posts or presentations. Wow, these library movers and shakers are real people like me with real lives! Wow, how sad. ;)

It can be hard to get into it at first. You just have to reach out and start following people. Twitter is social - you can’t do it alone.

But, once you have gotten the hang of it, it can also be hard to step away from it. I’ve had to learn that it’s OK to miss tweets. I don’t have to scroll back thru every tweet that I missed while sleeping or at lunch or in a meeting or teaching a workshop. I can just pick up the conversation in the middle and it won’t be the end of the world.

I hope. Nah, it’s OK. Right? ::bing:: oooo…what are they saying now??

May 16th, 2008 at 10:37 am
 19 

Not to break the unanimity, but my Twitter attempt was a failure–and as I read LSW chums talking about it, I think I’d best stay away for now.

Not because it would be pointless (that was the problem with my ALA attempt–it never resulted in any meetups), but because it would be interesting and a considerable distraction. Maybe the right kind of distraction, but for my own mindset a dangerous one.

On the other hand, just as LSW has been worthwhile, I suspect Twitter would be also. So I’m still torn…

May 16th, 2008 at 11:40 am
MegvsMeg
 20 

I hated Twitter a lot, and walked out of a Library Camp session on it. It just seemed so self-indulgent and conceited. That someone would want to give constant updates, as though the world could not live without knowing what they were doing.

I don’t know what happened.

On Metafilter, showing your Twitter was an option, and that led me to follow some really cool people. Then, I found out about the awesome library folks who were on Twitter, and I was hooked. It sticks for me though, because of the narratives (whether work-related or not), even if they are of people I haven’t met IRL. I like the stories, and I check it (even going back pages if I’ve missed some) because I want to find out what happened. I also like the random one-offs, and I appreciate learning about tech tools and reading blog posts that I would have ordinarily, due to my blog reluctance.

In my own tweets, it’s hard for me to find a balance between work (people I know from the internet) and nonwork (people I knew before Twitter). I have meatspace friends on there who absolutely do not care about citation management tools. I also do worry about sounding like a self-important jerk.

Sometimes I wonder what would happen if Twitter went away (and were not replaced), and I would definitely miss it, at least for awhile.

May 16th, 2008 at 12:26 pm
 21 

I only follow librarians and a few IA professionals. I see Twitter as a compliment to professional development, talking in the hallways, and getting advice. Because I’m not actually in a library at the moment, chatting on Twitter keeps me in touch with what’s going on. I also deleted my first Twitter account, because initially people weren’t using it as a discussion tool, it really was “what am I doing now”. I love that it has evolved to discussion and answering questions.

Twitter is one of the most essential websites I visit now.

May 16th, 2008 at 12:55 pm
 22 

I started a Twitter account a while ago, but never kept up with it until I got back into it recently. Similar to Brandi, the fact that a lot of people I knew and/or met at the last CiL were using it got me interested again. Twittering at the conference was a surprisingly rewarding experience. It was easy to find people at the conference because I was following them, and I got to “hear” bits of other presentations.
And because I’ve moved away from “home,” it’s been great being able to keep in touch with many of my friends.

May 16th, 2008 at 1:03 pm
 23 

I Twitter to raise awareness of my library. I keep it professional @ LPI_Library. I’m not addicted, 1-3 posts a day. I don’t want to scare anyone off with too much noise.

I do follow a bunch of folks. I drop in one or twice a day and read a screen or two. sometimes I’ll check the posts of a person to see if something important was covered.

Nice response to your request. Maybe I’ll try it.

May 16th, 2008 at 1:08 pm
Jill O'Neill
 24 

Twitter is compelling for me because it is an icebreaker. It makes it very easy for me to approach another professional (who may actually be a stranger to me) in order to ask a question, invite a presentation, etc. If I have even a shallow sense of your interests and professional expertise, it is easier for me to establish rapport.

Sometimes, the use of Twitter acts as a current awareness tool regarding issues or news. I follow several analysts on Twitter because they surface interesting material.

Sometimes, the use of Twitter allows me to see into another publishing professional’s world. I follow a CEO of a major publishing house on Twitter and his tweets surface issues or concerns in that sector of publishing that may or may not be similar to those of the publishing sector with whom I work.

May 16th, 2008 at 1:24 pm
 25 

I only signed up for Twitter this week, partly because I keep hearing you guys talking about it on Uncontrolled Vocabulary.

I was resistant to signing up because:
A. I’m a shy person who doesn’t really want to broadcast minute details of my life so I didn’t see a purpose for me.
B. Last summer I caved to the “Facebook is great” posts in the librarian blogosphere, and almost immediately after I signed up there was a Facebook backlash. Maybe I’ll kill Twitter too.

Anyhow, I’m still learning. It may be fun. It may be a distraction. But I’d really like it to have some benefit professionally as well.

May 16th, 2008 at 3:49 pm
 26 

I’ve tried it a number of times. Only recently is it getting more interesting. For the longest time it seemed like a lot of people talking about what they were eating. Sorry, too busy for that. Lately, I’m starting to find more valuable tweets.

The place I still really struggle is figuring out what to say myself. Concise is hard for me, so is telling random people random facts. Still haven’t hit my stride with this part at all.

May 17th, 2008 at 1:52 am
 27 

Dear Twitter,

I love ya, I hate ya, you irritate the heck outta me…

That’s how I feel about twitter. I really enjoy seeing bit and pieces of the lives of my friends that I would never have the opportunity to see without twitter. I hate having to go back through older tweets to catch up. I can go days without Twitter and often post only one or two twitts a day. I don’t take Twitter very seriously, it is just a nice little bit a decoration on my greater social network. But then I am a twitt!

May 17th, 2008 at 12:33 pm
 28 

[...] thoughts on Twitter: I recently posted to Greg’s request for opinions and thoughts on Twitter where I discuss [...]

May 18th, 2008 at 12:51 am
Luc
 29 

I don’t use Twitter. I keep hearing about it, I know lots of people who do, I keep reading about it. My question(s) would be. Is it worth to spend the time to learn yet another tool? Is it easy to use, so the spent time would not be too extensive? Is it intuitive? What do people use it for the most? When is the use of this tool the most efficient and for what activities/communication(s)/situations? When did people find it to be not useful? And why? If I want to know how my friends are doing, I call them, e-mail them, leave them a message on facebook, leave them a message on my space, go visit them, text them, IM them, skype them….so do I really need to twitter them as well?

May 19th, 2008 at 11:48 am
Greg
 30 

Just wanted to quickly say thank you to everyone who commented on this post. An amazing response. There are a few people I owe specific responses to in here, but I’m a little short on time, so I beg you to accept my apologies for the delay. Hope to be back soon for follow-up.

May 19th, 2008 at 1:24 pm
 31 

[...] the one where I went fishing for comments on Twitter received 30 [...]

May 19th, 2008 at 11:07 pm
 32 

[...] have been challenges. The Twitter question generated so many comments so quickly that I was overwhelmed before I even began. I ended up [...]

May 19th, 2008 at 11:24 pm

Leave a reply

Name (*)
Mail (will not be published) (*)
URI
Comment
« Back to text comment