Archive for October, 2003

22
Oct

Still here

   Posted by: Greg   in Commentary

Howdy everyone. You can blame my absence on this pesky World Series, but in trying to catch up, I came across some interesting stuff.

There’s been plenty of talk about comment spam lately, particularly amongst Movable Type users, myself included. Since I’ve installed Jay Allen’s MT-Blacklist, I haven’t had a single incidence…until yesterday. But this wasn’t the garden variety “phentermine and viagra” comment spam. Nope, this was from a PhD student promoting a weblog covering the Invisible Web.

Now, I have mixed emotions about this. On the one hand, the content is interesting, relevant and I’m glad to know about it. However, the author is using my comments as a publicity source, without providing a comment relevant to the discussion. So I won’t link directly to this individual’s blog, but invite you to check out the last post’s comments for the URL.

Having mentioned the comments on the last post, I should add a pronounced “Wowzer!” My innocent little suggestion turned into quite the discussion. There were mentions of blogs, wikis, indexes and collaborative information systems. And all I wanted was a little more discussion of what librarians do, when they do what they do. Let’s not get too fancy here and take all the fun out of it.

Oh, and here’s an excerpt from an article that sums up some of my sentiments about the Librarian Action Figure:

“Nancy Pearl looks like a very nice person and I’m sure I would like her if I met her. So, my disappointment isn’t with whom they picked as the model, but the way she is presented. She is dressed in what could be described as predictable librarian clothes — a conservative suit, probably extremely comfortable shoes and glasses. I’m sure it is the shallow part of me that makes me want this, but I wish she could look snazzier — you know, shiny or elegant or glittery — so maybe some girl somewhere might see her and say to themselves: Wow, I want one of these, she’s cool; or something like that. And she would then want to be a librarian because her action figure looks not only intelligent and capable, but also exciting and brave and modern.

I know appearances can be deceiving and so Ms. Pearl is probably all of those. But I wish it was easier to tell by looking.”

And since I expect to get my chance to meet her soon, I’ll let you know.

10
Oct

Teaching each other

   Posted by: Greg   in Commentary

You know what I find lacking in the LIS blogosphere? I see a fair amount of writing that mentions different reference transactions (refgrunt, anyone?), but I never learn anything about how our diverse collection of information professionals goes about handling these situations.

What proved the be the best source for “the history of music in Oregon during the 1850’s?” What sources would you in fact recommend for a patron “researching public health policies?”

Why don’t we share more? Maybe we’re not willing to have our techniques scrutinized by other so-called experts. That’s understandable, but at the same time, I’d like to think I can be accountable for the guidance I provide. Plus, by sharing our approaches with the blogosphere, we’re likely to hear alternate ideas from our brilliant cohorts. Perhaps there’ll be some lively debate. Who can say for sure? All I know is that we have a lot to teach each other, the kind of insight you just can’t get in a few hours of a grad school course.

We have an opportunity to propagate more than our opinions about Ashcroft and OCLC (although these are clearly worthwhile pursuits that I have no intention of abandoning). Rather than saying over and over again that free-web search engines are not necessarily the best approach, let’s start demonstrating it. We are not guardians of arcane knowledge, but information guides of the first order. So quit guarding your knowledge and let the guide in you shine through.

10
Oct

Listed and Blacklisted

   Posted by: Greg   in Bloggery

I’ve been losing some steam lately in my blogging, but when I saw that Steven had mentioned Open Stacks in his recent presentation (slide 28 - in quite esteemed company, I might add), well, I panicked and realized I’d better step up my attention. Welcome SLSers and others who have found me by way of Steven’s always generous linkage.

So I’ve been having lots of problems with comment spam lately, as have numerous other authors. Aaron suggested we pool resources and share IP addresses of comment spammers. It appears that Scott Johnson at Feedster has put the idea into action. He has a form where you can report the IP address and spammed links that appear in your comments. The blacklist is in OPML format for maximum flexibility. The list is pretty short, but I imagine it will grow quickly. I could add about 20 addresses myself, but unfortunately, I deleted all the spam comments, so I can’t contribute the spammed links. I’m sure there’ll be other opportunities. Anyway, nice work, Scott.